
11.3K
Downloads
313
Episodes
An Anime/Animated Retrospective Podcast ranging from the realms of Ghibli to Godzilla and beyond. Join resident nerd co-hosts Jonathan Kwiatkowski and Dan Ryan as they travel through spirit realms, new, fascinating worlds, and fly through the skies in order to prove that Anime Was (Not) A Mistake.
Episodes

4 days ago
Episode 310: Princess Tutu: Part 3
4 days ago
4 days ago
A dance of ravens and crows begins anew on this episode of Anime Was (Not) A Mistake as the curtains rise for a second act. We continue the performance that is Princess Tutu as all of our characters have seemingly met their storybook ends. However, all is not as it seems, in this anime. A duck longs to be a swan, a crow yearns to be a lover. A knight a storyteller and a prince to be free. As our pieces are posed to dance on pointe in the finale, what will happen? And will we have to make some shocking changes to the script. I've seen some intrigue in the courtyard and as your "best" friend I advise you have a public fight in front of the whole school! Only by challenging your fate and putting on your pointe shoes can you hope to reach this story's end!
Rate, Review, Subscribe, and Listen to Us on Podbean/iTunes/Stitcher/Spotify
Follow us on Instagram:@animewasnotamistakepodcast Or on Facebook:@animewasnotamistakepod
Music Provided:
“Sis Puella Magica!” – Yuki Kajiura – Aniplex – Puella Magi Madoka Magica - Puella Magi Madoka Magica Music Collection - 2011
“Zoltraak” – Evan Call feat Alina Lesnik – Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End - 2023
“Dungeon Meshi Main Theme” – Yasunori Mitsuda feat. Lauren McGlynn [ANÚNA] – Delicious in Dungeon/Dungeon Meshi - 2024

Sunday Apr 06, 2025
Episode 309: Delicious in Dungeon X Toriko (Part VI)
Sunday Apr 06, 2025
Sunday Apr 06, 2025
In what’s already being hailed as our best episode yet (by us), we dive into another combo platter of Delicious in Dungeon and Toriko. First, Laios and his friends arrive at the dungeon’s Sixth Level. After dealing with some uncanny shapeshifters, the party gains a new member in the form of the beastman ninja Izutsumi. A supernatural detour then brings the party to the legendary Golden Country, a paradise within the dungeon that remains frozen in time. There, a surprising revelation leads Laios to question his destiny. Back on the surface, Kabru discusses similarly existential matters with the Canaries, a group of elven dungeon specialists known for leaving destruction in their wake. Next, in Toriko, our heroes have to get past a troop of dangerous Troll Kongs to reach the extra-flavorful fruit they guard. Finally, Toriko and Komatsu team up with another member of the Four Heavenly Kings to find the rare Puffer Whale. Please remember to check under your pillow for nightmare clams and enjoy a giant wheel of cheese for today’s well-mellowed episode of Anime Was (Not) A Mistake!
Rate, Review, Subscribe, and Listen to Us on Podbean/iTunes/Stitcher/Spotify
Follow us on Instagram:@animewasnotamistakepodcast Or on Facebook:@animewasnotamistakepod
Music Provided:
“Sis Puella Magica!” – Yuki Kajiura – Aniplex – Puella Magi Madoka Magica - Puella Magi Madoka Magica Music Collection - 2011
“Zoltraak” – Evan Call feat Alina Lesnik – Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End - 2023
“Dungeon Meshi Main Theme” – Yasunori Mitsuda feat. Lauren McGlynn [ANÚNA] – Delicious in Dungeon/Dungeon Meshi - 2024

Sunday Mar 30, 2025
Episode 308: Sinister Six XLII: Love Never Dies (2011)
Sunday Mar 30, 2025
Sunday Mar 30, 2025
Christine, Christine? Tonight, on Anime Was (Not) A Mistake presents Sinister Six's first true blue direct sequel with The Phantom of the Opera's musical continuation Love Never Dies (2011). We take a trip to Coney Island in the hopes of making 10 long years of waiting make any sort of sense in the musical theater canon. Christine Daae arrives to sing an aria or two with her fractured family, only to find out that her power as one of theater's greatest heroines has no effect in this land of sideshows and jaded chorus girls. Bathing Beauties, please tune in and offer us your commentary on this controversial cabaret. With a son that is only 10 YEARS OLD what kind of intrigue or subterfuge could take place.? We ask on this podcast, to enjoy as our "dear old friends" hoping that you will hear us sing once more. Beneath a moonless sky....
Podbean/iTunes/Stitcher/Spotify
Follow us on Instagram:@animewasnotamistakepodcast Or on Facebook:@animewasnotamistakepod
Music Provided by:
"Danse Macabre" Saint-Saëns - Rock/Metal Version Cover – EXMORTUS TV
“Live and Learn” – Crush 40 - Main Theme of Sonic: Adventure 2
“Chromaggia” – Repo! The Genetic Opera: Original Motion Picture Soundtrack

Sunday Mar 23, 2025
Episode 307: Sinister Six XLI: Squirm (1976)
Sunday Mar 23, 2025
Sunday Mar 23, 2025
The latest installment of Sinister Six digs way too deep into the “natural horror” genre with 1976’s Squirm. When a freak electrical storm strikes the town of Fly Creek, angry worms emerge from the ground and start attacking people. As the worms unleash their wrath one tree at a time, city boy Mick arrives in town to visit his long-distance girlfriend Geri. Fly Creek’s very sweaty Sheriff Jim immediately suspects Mick when odd, worm-adjacent occurrences begin popping up. Mick also has to contend with Geri’s mother Naomi (who’s basically in a different movie) and her odd neighbor Rick. After they discover the first of the worms’ many victims, Mick and Geri race to solve the mystery of whatever’s nibbling away at Fly Creek. They probably only have until nightfall, when worms are at their most powerful. Probably. We’re not really sure what the moral of this story is, but we promise that it involves more worms than you’re expecting. Remember to wear your greasiest shirt, drink a few egg creams, and eat plenty of spaghetti for today’s uncomfortably-soggy episode of Anime Was (Not) A Mistake!
Podbean/iTunes/Stitcher/Spotify
Follow us on Instagram:@animewasnotamistakepodcast Or on Facebook:@animewasnotamistakepod
Music Provided by:
"Danse Macabre" Saint-Saëns - Rock/Metal Version Cover – EXMORTUS TV
“Live and Learn” – Crush 40 - Main Theme of Sonic: Adventure 2
“Chromaggia” – Repo! The Genetic Opera: Original Motion Picture Soundtrack

Sunday Mar 16, 2025
Episode 306: Wicked (2024)
Sunday Mar 16, 2025
Sunday Mar 16, 2025
Good News! In a most scandalosious turn of events, that still sticks to the vague principals of magical girls and anime, our humble little podcast is heading down the yellow brick road with Wicked: Part One (2024). Although our intrepid hosts are well versed in the magic of weebdom, we needed another more attuned to the art of showtunes able to decipher The Grimmerie. That's right fellow Ozians, Gabe Rivera is here, descending in a steampunk bubble to set the record straight. While this is happening Dan is channeling his emotions in the hopes that one day he can fly, all of course under Jonathan's totally not menacing and manipilutidiness madness... Topics discussed within are which type of Elphaba and Galinda watch of our cohosts are. A deep dive into the lore of Gregory Maguire's novels. And the introduction of the ethereal being that is Dulcibear. Something has changed within us and Anime Was (Not) A Mistake will never be the same. OOOOOOOH AH AAAAAAA AHA AAAAAAAA AHAAAAAAA!
Rate, Review, Subscribe, and Listen to Us on Podbean/iTunes/Stitcher/Spotify
Follow us on Instagram:@animewasnotamistakepodcast Or on Facebook:@animewasnotamistakepod
Music Provided:
“Sis Puella Magica!” – Yuki Kajiura – Aniplex – Puella Magi Madoka Magica - Puella Magi Madoka Magica Music Collection - 2011
“Zoltraak” – Evan Call feat Alina Lesnik – Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End - 2023
“Dungeon Meshi Main Theme” – Yasunori Mitsuda feat. Lauren McGlynn [ANÚNA] – Delicious in Dungeon/Dungeon Meshi - 2024

Sunday Mar 09, 2025
Episode 305: Delicious in Dungeon Part V X Toriko X ONE PIECE!?
Sunday Mar 09, 2025
Sunday Mar 09, 2025
The dice have stopped rolling, but Anime Was (Not) A Mistake has more dungeons and delicacies to explore. Immediately back by popular demand, Delicious in Dungeon resumes with Laios and his friends searching for an exit. A tense meeting with the warrior Shuro forces the party to reevaluate their ultimate goal. Falin has been transformed into a terrifying monster by the Mad Mage, and Laios cannot risk the Island Lord going after her. Defeating the Mad Mage himself may be the only option that remains, but are our heroes really the best party for the job? Continuing the trend of pairing Delicious in Dungeon with a special side dish, we’ll briefly step into the colorful (and flavorful) world of Toriko. While the Gourmet Hunter Toriko is beefy enough on his own…we advise leaving room for a THIRD course of shonen action. Please make sure that your Barbecue Pig keeps its cool during today’s sweet, spicy, and salty installment of Anime Was (Not) A Mistake!
Rate, Review, Subscribe, and Listen to Us on Podbean/iTunes/Stitcher/Spotify
Follow us on Instagram:@animewasnotamistakepodcast Or on Facebook:@animewasnotamistakepod
Music Provided:
“Sis Puella Magica!” – Yuki Kajiura – Aniplex – Puella Magi Madoka Magica - Puella Magi Madoka Magica Music Collection - 2011
“Zoltraak” – Evan Call feat Alina Lesnik – Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End - 2023
“Dungeon Meshi Main Theme” – Yasunori Mitsuda feat. Lauren McGlynn [ANÚNA] – Delicious in Dungeon/Dungeon Meshi - 2024

Sunday Mar 02, 2025
Episode 304: Princess Tutu: Part 2
Sunday Mar 02, 2025
Sunday Mar 02, 2025
A duck, a raven, a prince a knight. Some stories come to an end and other questions arise on this episode of Anime Was (Not) A Mistake. Today on the podcast, we see as Duck, Rue, Mytho, and Fakir deal with their assigned roles in a cosmic story dictated before them. Should a sword of swans be used to shatter a prince's heat? Could a knight forgo the innocence of others in order to save his charged sovereign? Will a princess of crows discover who she truly is? And last, but certainly not least, can a duck prove her love without the use of words? Come dance with us and find out!
Rate, Review, Subscribe, and Listen to Us on Podbean/iTunes/Stitcher/Spotify
Follow us on Instagram:@animewasnotamistakepodcast Or on Facebook:@animewasnotamistakepod
Music Provided:
“Sis Puella Magica!” – Yuki Kajiura – Aniplex – Puella Magi Madoka Magica - Puella Magi Madoka Magica Music Collection - 2011
“Zoltraak” – Evan Call feat Alina Lesnik – Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End - 2023
“Dungeon Meshi Main Theme” – Yasunori Mitsuda feat. Lauren McGlynn [ANÚNA] – Delicious in Dungeon/Dungeon Meshi - 2024

Sunday Feb 23, 2025
Episode 303: Princess Tutu: Part 1
Sunday Feb 23, 2025
Sunday Feb 23, 2025
Once upon a time...there was an anime podcast (Anime Was Not A Mistake) with two cohosts. One of them. A shonen fan through and through, the other, a man of taste not afraid to embrace the beauty of all that was maho shojo. "I know!" said the man with taste. "I'll introduce my rival to the classic magical girl anime Princess Tutu. Once I do that, he's bound to see the error of his ways." In a series devoted to both ballet and fairytales we are introduced to our heroine Duck, who is literally a duck, turned girl, turned into Princess Tutu. When given the quest to restore a storybook prince's heart shards lessons on love, emotion, and the ever-changing hands of fate and destiny are presented through dance and classical music. Suddenly as the man with taste cackled gleefully over his plan the shonen fan entered. "Jonathan, what are you doing in there? Some of us have got to use the bathroom!" "Nothing! Nothing at all!" screamed the man with taste, as the toilet flushed...
Rate, Review, Subscribe, and Listen to Us on Podbean/iTunes/Stitcher/Spotify
Follow us on Instagram:@animewasnotamistakepodcast Or on Facebook:@animewasnotamistakepod
Music Provided:
“Sis Puella Magica!” – Yuki Kajiura – Aniplex – Puella Magi Madoka Magica - Puella Magi Madoka Magica Music Collection - 2011
“Zoltraak” – Evan Call feat Alina Lesnik – Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End - 2023
“Dungeon Meshi Main Theme” – Yasunori Mitsuda feat. Lauren McGlynn [ANÚNA] – Delicious in Dungeon/Dungeon Meshi - 2024

Sunday Feb 16, 2025
Episode 302: Record of Lodoss War: Part V
Sunday Feb 16, 2025
Sunday Feb 16, 2025
Our Weebs & Wyrms arc comes to close with the grand finale of Record of Lodoss War. Heroes and villains converge upon Fire Dragon Mountain, where the legendary dragon Shooting Star guards the Scepter of Domination. The dark wizard Wagnard intends to use the scepter to awaken and control Kardis, the primordial goddess of chaos and destruction. As evil ascends, Parn and his allies journey to the island of Marmo. Lord Ashram, betrayed by Wagnard but still possessing the Demon Sword, also moves to foil the wizard’s plan. The final battle for Lodoss begins as the ritual to resurrect Kardis is set into motion. Ancient blades collide, dragons clash, and Slayn breaks the bro code on today’s earth-shattering installment of Anime Was (Not) A Mistake!
Rate, Review, Subscribe, and Listen to Us on Podbean/iTunes/Stitcher/Spotify
Follow us on Instagram:@animewasnotamistakepodcast Or on Facebook:@animewasnotamistakepod
Music Provided:
“Sis Puella Magica!” – Yuki Kajiura – Aniplex – Puella Magi Madoka Magica - Puella Magi Madoka Magica Music Collection - 2011
“Zoltraak” – Evan Call feat Alina Lesnik – Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End - 2023
“Dungeon Meshi Main Theme” – Yasunori Mitsuda feat. Lauren McGlynn [ANÚNA] – Delicious in Dungeon/Dungeon Meshi - 2024

Sunday Feb 09, 2025
Episode 301: Delicious in Dungeon X Record of Lodoss War: Part IV
Sunday Feb 09, 2025
Sunday Feb 09, 2025
Fated battles await in today’s exciting installment of Anime Was (Not) A Mistake: Weebs & Wyrms! First, Dungeon Meshi reaches its halfway point as the party finally faces the infamous Red Dragon. The battle pushes Laios and his friends to their limits, and a grim discovery afterward proves hard to swallow. Marcille may have a solution in the form of ancient dark magic, but the dungeon (and its master) won’t make things easy. In Record of Lodoss War, King Fahn and Emperor Beld finally face one another on the battlefield. However, their duel ends with both rulers dead after Karla the Grey Witch intervenes to sow chaos. Certain that Lodoss will never know peace with Karla controlling things, Parn and his party go to confront the witch directly. Sacrifices will be made, but the stability of Lodoss is far from guaranteed. Dragons rise and dragons fall on today’s flame-grilled episode of Anime Was (Not) A Mistake!
Rate, Review, Subscribe, and Listen to Us on Podbean/iTunes/Stitcher/Spotify
Follow us on Instagram:@animewasnotamistakepodcast Or on Facebook:@animewasnotamistakepod
Music Provided:
“Sis Puella Magica!” – Yuki Kajiura – Aniplex – Puella Magi Madoka Magica - Puella Magi Madoka Magica Music Collection - 2011
“Zoltraak” – Evan Call feat Alina Lesnik – Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End - 2023
“Dungeon Meshi Main Theme” – Yasunori Mitsuda feat. Lauren McGlynn [ANÚNA] – Delicious in Dungeon/Dungeon Meshi - 2024